Secret White House Tapes

892-009a

About this recording

892-009a
  • President Richard M. Nixon
  • Lee Kuan Yew
  • Ernest S. Monteiro
  • Henry A. Kissinger
  • Manolo Sanchez
April 10, 1973
Conversation No. 892-9

Date: April 10, 1973
Time: Unknown between 11:10 am and 12:18 pm
Location: Oval Office

The President met with Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew, Ambassador Ernest S. Monteiro, and
Henry A. Kissinger.

Greetings

Photographs

-Arrangements

-Rose Garden

-Types of plants

President’s re-election

-Margin of victory

-Compared to Yew’s election


Photographs

-Arrangements


The President et al. left at 11:11 am.
-16-


NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM


Tape Subject Log

(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

[Photograph session in Rose Garden]

The recording cut off while the President et al. were in the Rose Garden.

The recording system re-engaged.

The President et al. entered at 11:13 am.

Photographs

-White House photograph

-Distribution


Vietnam
-President’s decisions

-Difficulties

-Protest marches

-Number of marchers
-Cambodia, May 8th decision
-Blockade
-December bombing
-December bombing

-Public reaction

-Press reaction
-Press relationship with Democrats
-Portrayal of President
-North Vietnam perception
-December 1972
-“Universal criticism” of President
-Compared to Cambodia
-“Genocide,” “insanity”
-Lee’s reaction
-Location
-Paris, from London
-Conversation with Georges J. R. Pompidou
-Setback
-Ceasefire agreement
-Ceasefire agreement
-17-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-US withdrawal, return of Prisoners of War [POWs]

-Incentives

-Violations

-Failure to withdraw from Cambodia and Laos
-South Vietnam
-Hanoi’s intentions
-US public statements contrasted with private concern
-US-Soviet Union relations
-Politburo
-US withdrawal
-North Vietnam, South Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos
-Legal justification for continued US involvement
-Bombing of Cambodia
-Violations of ceasefire agreement
-Agreement compared to treaty
-US Senate

-Difficulties

-Press reaction

-US Congress

-Senate

-Need for withdrawal

-Timing

-Kissinger’s assessment

-Michael J. (“Mike”) Mansfield

-Troop drawdown

-J. William Fulbright

-Credibility

-Mansfield

-Charles McC. Mathias, Jr.

-Press
-Motives

-US withdrawal

-Southeast Asia

-Journalistic standards
-Lee’s speech to National Press Club
-Technology
-Globalization
-18-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Disengagement with Vietnam

-US sphere of influence

-US withdrawal

-Press coverage


Neo-isolationists
-US withdrawal
-Southeast Asia, Korea
-Implications for South Vietnam

-Treaty with Japan

-“Asia for Asians”

-Europe

-Unilateralism

-Arms limitations negotiation

-“Old internationalists”

-Marshall Plan

-Point Four

-US responsibility

-US isolationism

-Domestic issues

-Education, housing
-Contrasted with Defense Department spending
-Congress
-Veto
-Water and sewer program
-“Leader class”

-Great Britain

-Intellectual leadership

-Contrasted with Edward R. G. Heath
-France, Germany, Western Europe
-Global responsibilities
-Soviet Union, People’s Republic of China [PRC]
-Europe
-Lee’s assessment
-“Men in authority” contrasted with “establishment intellectuals”
-Heath, Henry A. Carrington, Sir Alexander F. (“Alec”)
Douglas-Home
-19-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Pompidou
-Lord Rees-Mogg [editor of London Times]
-Conversation with Lee
-US withdrawal
-US nuclear response
-Credibility
-Rees-Mogg’s response
-France, Great Britain
-PRC, Soviet Union
-Competition
-Future president [?]
-Winston S. Churchill
-Biography by Charles McMoran Wilson [Lord Moran]
-Candid quality
-Triumph and Tragedy
-Franklin D. Roosevelt
-Soviet Union
-Geopolitical perspective
-Compared to Roosevelt
-Soviet intentions
-Yalta Agreement
-Charles E. (“Chip”) Bohlen’s conversation
with President
-Adherence
-Poland
-Compared to Indochina

Vietnam
-Threats, incentives
-North Vietnam compliance with peace agreement
-US Congress

-US aid

-Military strike

-Incentive, leverage
-South Vietnam military strength
-US influence on Soviet Union and PRC
-20-


NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM


Tape Subject Log

(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

Southeast Asia
-Lee’s advice
-Conversation with Kissinger
-Confidence in President’s policies
-US Congress
-Press
-Realization of proposals

Manolo Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 11:13 am.

Refreshments

Sanchez left at an unknown time before 12:18 pm.

Sanchez entered at an unknown time after 11:13 am.

Southeast Asia

-South Vietnam

-Non-Communist government

-Lee’s assessment

-Leadership


Refreshments

Sanchez left at an unknown time before 12:18 pm.

Vietnam

-US withdrawal

-Honorable disengagement

-South Vietnam

-Leadership

-“Great power politics” compared to small nations
-Power relations
-US compared to PRC, Soviet Union
-Change
-Orthodoxy compared to reform
-Possible economic and social policy changes
-21-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-South Vietnam

-Possibility for success

-Reliance on military strength

-Communist preference

-Communists

-Compared to North Vietnam

-Viability

-Social, economic base
-North Vietnam’s support
-Assimilation
-Municipal government
-Police, army
-Distinction between North Vietnam and South Vietnam
-North Vietnam
-Autonomy
-Viet Cong
-Possible effects
-US aid
-Allocation
-Funding for social and economic policy compared to
North Vietnam military spending
-Hanoi, Viet Cong
-Military expenditures
-Effects

Refreshments

Southeast Asia
-Danger for South Vietnam
-North Vietnam
-Hanoi

-Compliance with peace agreement

-US aid

-PRC, Soviet Union

-South Vietnam

-Arms support

-Expenditures

-22-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-War

-Nguyen Van Thieu

-Peace agreement

-Power-sharing with North Vietnam

-Municipal government

-Peace agreement

-North Vietnam acceptance

-Incentives

-Stick and carrot
-Certainty
-US intentions
-Miscalculations
-Statements by press, US Congress
-Possible miscalculations
-Leadership
-Lee’s assessment
-Disconnection
-Exposure
-Kissinger
-President’s assessment
-Contrasted with Le Duc Tho
-President’s conversation with Prisoners of War
[POWs]

-Experience in prison

-Kissinger’s experience

-Dinners

-Cambodia

-North Vietnam aims

-Compared to South Vietnam
-Risks
-Strategy
-Military troops
-Khmer Rouge
-Likelihood

US foreign policy
-US Congress
-23-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Intellectual class
-Weakness
-Neo-isolationism
-Withdrawal from Europe, Asia
-Korea, Vietnam
-Outcome
-Non-communist state
-Compared to Great Britain

-Heath, Douglas-Home, Carrington

-Intellectual class

-Compared to France

-Pompidou

-Compared to Germany

-US leadership
-Need for strength
-Support of Congress, public
-Framework
-Attitudes about global role
-World War I

-Great Britain, France

-Kaiser Wilhem II

-World War II

-France, Great Britain

-Japan, Germany

-Great Britain, France

-Reluctance

-US rise to power
-Intentionality
-Mao Tse-tung [?]
-Effect on policy
-Vietnam War
-Conduct
-US entry
-Gradual escalation

-President’s doubts

-Completion

-Honor

-24-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-US Senate proposal

-POWs, withdrawal

-Effect on US reputation

-Trust, respect
-Cost
-Effect on US role in world affairs
-Isolationism compared to participation
-President’s previous conversation with Lee in Singapore
-Soviet Union, PRC

-Superpower status

-Relations with US

-Desirability
-Relations with Soviet Union, PRC
-Opportunity
-Strategy
-Compared to confrontation, uneasy negotiations
-US position
-Strength, trustworthiness, respect
-Nixon Doctrine
-Interpretation

-State Department

-Mansfield

-Vietnam involvement contrasted with self-reliance

-Asia, Latin America

-Nuclear deterent

-Isolationism
-Press coverage
-Public opinion
-Faculty of Ivy League universities
-Editorial staff of New York Times, Washington Post, Time,
Newsweek
-Leadership at television [TV] networks
-American Broadcasting Company [ABC], National
Broadcasting Company [NBC], Columbia Broadcasting
System [CBS]
-White House Press Corps

-Magnitude of problem

-25-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-President, Kissinger

-Agreement

-Leadership

-Kissinger’s assessment
-Europe

-Monetary policy

-Balance of payments

-Currency parity

-Timetable

-End of President’s term

-Scope of planning

-Vietnam

-Effect on public opinion

-Vietnam

-Opponents of President’s policy

-George S. McGovern

-Resilience

-Relations with Communist powers

-Weakness

-Effect on global stability

Japan
-President’s previous meeting with Lee
-Location

-Ambitions

-Compared with Germany

-United Nations [UN] Security Council
-Role in world affairs

-Vietnam peace talks

-Desires

-Kissinger’s preference

-Western alliance

-Western alliance

-Monetary and economic interests

-US relations with Europe

-Monetary and trade policy

-Inclusion of Japan

-26-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Economy

-Size

-Military capability

-Hypothetical nuclear capability
-Possibility of offensive weapons
-Independence of Japan foreign policy
-Global stability
-Economy
-Trade relations with Western Europe, US
-Report from institute in Brussels
-Trade with Southeast Asia
-Percent
-Growth
-Imports
-Raw materials
-Exports
-Manufacturing
-Trade with US compared to Western Europe
-Opportunity
-Possibility for peace, prosperity
-Tariffs
-Possible effect
-Need for inclusion
-Role in Western security
-Trade surplus
-Western Europe
-Kakeui Tanaka
-Domestic market
-US
-President’s previous meeting with bipartisan Congressional leaders
US trade legislation
-Trade imbalance with Japan

Singapore
-Exports to US
-Textiles, shoes
-Difficulties for US
-27-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Colonial legacy

-Great Britain

-Exports

-Shoes, textiles

-Dependence

-Problems

-Europe, US

-Computers

-Japan markets

-Imports

-Performance

-Response to challenges


Indonesia
-Lee’s forthcoming visit
-Importance
-Leadership
-Jakarta

-Decentralization

-Military generals

-Inclusion

-Technocrats

-Civilians

-Compared with Thailand

-Ruling military generals

-Relationship between power and wealth

-Islamic tradition

-Exception

-Dr. [Unintelligible name]
-Corruption
-Mohammed Hatta’s remarks
-Culture
-Effect on development
-Seminar at Southeast Asia Institute
-Role of corruption
-Rationalization
-28-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

Meeting agenda

PRC
-Lee’s vantage point
-US policy
-Lee’s assessment

-Boundary

-Chou En-lai, Mao Tse-tung

-Longevity

-Possible effect on foreign relations

-Trade relations

-Technology

-Soviet Union

-Boeings from US

-Great Britain

-Boeing

-Diversification

-Japan

-Common market

-Soviet Union

-Second-strike capability

-Compared to US

-Conscience
-Military

-Second-strike capability

-Ground forces

-India

-Population

-Relations with Soviet Union

-Military aid

-Relations with Pakistan

-Southeast Asia

-Vietnam settlement

-Role of North Vietnam

-Japan

-Peaceful direction

-Respect

-29-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

-Fear
-US, Hawaii

-Objection to capitalist system

-Conscience

-Historical relations with Mexico
-Texas annexation
-Spanish-American War
-Twentieth-century foreign policy
-World War I, World War II, Korean War, Vietnam War
-Territorial expansion
-Perception of threat
-PRC’s propaganda
-Relations compared to Europe, Soviet Union
-US role in Japan, Taiwan
-Future prospects

-Japan, PRC

-Succession

-Consolidation

-Trade relations

-Technology
-Dependence on US
-Compared with balance between US, Western
Europe, Japan
-Supply
-Current leadership
-Lessons
-Soviet Union

Golf
-Lee’s handicap
-Compared to President’s handicap

-Course around official residence

-Benefits

-Physical exertion

-Trees, fresh air

-“Antidote to the Committee Room”

-30-


NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM


Tape Subject Log

(rev. September-2012)

Conversation No. 892-9 (cont’d)

Presidential golf balls
-Compared to Lee’s free advice

An unknown man entered at an unknown time after 11:13 am.

Golf balls

-Donald McI. Kendall

-Wilson brand


Request for box of golf balls

The unknown man left at an unknown time before 12:18 pm.

Golf balls
-Waterholes

Forthcoming State Dinner
-Irish opera singer, Mary Costa
-Prettiness

Presentation of Presidential gifts
-Golf balls

The President et al. left at 12:18 pm.
Secret White House Tapes |

892-009a

More Richard M. Nixon Recordings

View all Richard M. Nixon tapes
893–1
audio icon
893–10
audio icon
893–11
audio icon
893–12
audio icon
893–13
audio icon
893–14
audio icon
44–142
audio icon
44–143
audio icon
44–144
audio icon
44–145
audio icon