Secret White House Tapes

868–8

About this recording

868–8
  • President Richard M. Nixon
  • George P. Shultz
  • Arthur F. Burns
  • Roy L. Ash
  • Herbert Stein
  • Paul A. Volcker
  • UNKNOWN
  • Ronald L. Ziegler
  • Henry Ahlgram
March 3, 1973
Conversation No. 868-8

Date: March 3, 1973
Time: Unknown between 10:08 am and 11:50 am
Location: Oval Office

The President met with George P. Shultz.

Press conference

Paul A. Volcker
-Location
-Work on negotiations
-Meeting with President
-Participation in meeting

Arthur F. Burns, Roy L. Ash, Herbert L. Stein, and Paul A. Volcker entered at 10:08 am.

Treasury department
-British pound
-Dollar

Volcker
-Praise for work

US dollar
-Discussion
-Format
-Memorandum
-Stein

Meeting
-Council of Economic Advisors [CEA]
-Ezra Solomon
-Wives of officials

Business confidence
-Sense of anxiety
-Inflation
-9-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Rise
-Interest rates
-Rise
-International money markets
-Slowdown of growth
-Deflationary pressures

Inflation
-Phase III [voluntary wage and price controls]
-Food prices
-Devaluation

An unknown man entered at an unknown time after 10:08 am.

Refreshment

The unknown man left at an unknown time before 11:50 am.

Inflation
-Monetary supply
-Budget
-Balance

Burns’s statement
-Joint Economic Committee

Interest rates
-Question at press conference
-President’s answer
-Explanation of money supply
-Over inflation
-Economic growth
-Compared to fiscal year 1968, 1969
-Burns’s testimony
-Credit crunch
-Fear on Wall Street
-Federal Reserve
-Psychology of concern
-10-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


Inflation
-Phase III
-Supply and demand
-Rates
-Moderation
-Food prices
-Reasons for confidence
-Food prices
-Problems
-Cheese
-Memorandum
-Tariff Commission
-Letter
-Investigation
-Milk producers
-Influence on Wilbur D. Mills
-Mills
-Telephone call to President
-Dealing with administration
-Patrick J. Lucey
-Governor of Wisconsin
-Cheese
-Political problems
-Mills
-Talk with President

Interest rates
-Increases
-Continuation
-Dangers
-Overexpansion, recession

International monetary markets
-Sources of instability
-Domestic implications
-Avoidance of adverse consequences
-David M. Kennedy
-Compared to Burns
-Currency circulation
-11-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Investment [?]
-Future structure

Monetary policy
-Future expansion, slowdown
-New York
-Inventories
-Manufacturing, finished goods
-January 1973
-Demand
-Accumulation
-New business orders
-Slowdowns
-Dangers
-Shortfalls in money supply
-Unemployment

Administration’s policy
-Flexibility
-Fiscal policy
-Burns’s proposal
-Investment credit

Economy
-Compared with mid-1960's
-Declining unemployment, rising inflation
-Money supply
-Inflation
-Tax reductions [1965]
-Personal and corporate income taxes
-Excise taxes
-Increased government spending
-\"Great Society programs
-Expansionary money supply
-Vietnam War
-Inflation [1963]
-Raw materials
-Wholesale prices
-Overstimulation
-12-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Effects
-Budget deficits
-Current Economic situation
-Full employment
-Fiscal, monetary policy
-Moderation

Taxes
-Investment tax credit
-Power of presidency
-Role of Congress
-Problems
-Responsibility
-Actions on President's proposals
-Modifications in President's proposals
-Problems for buyers
-Speculation
-Delays until Congress acts
-Destabilization potential

Shultz
-Testimony before Congress
-Date

Tax rates
-Flexibility
-Personal income
-Congress procedures
-Presidential requests on tax changes
-Fast track
-Rates percentiles
-Requests to Congress
-Procedure

Ronald L. Ziegler entered at 10:32 am.

President's conversation with Peter J. Brennan
-Accident
-Visit to site
-13-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Safety regulations
-Injuries, deaths
-Building collapse

Brennan
-Visit to high-rise apartment collapse
-Construction background

Ziegler left at 10:35 am.

Fiscal policy
-Investment tax credit
-Application

Credit
-Uncertainty
-Attacks by labor, liberals
-Administration's position
-Slowdown of investment
-Increased taxes

Federal Reserve study
-Congressional request
-Housing market
-Instability, fluctuations
-Reasons for study
-Method of stabilization
-Construction
-Proposals
-Economic stabilization
-Release of funds
-Future problems in housing industry

Investment tax credit
-Political sensitivity
-Flexibility
-Economic stimulus
-Restraint
-Housing industry
-14-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Fiscal policy
-Tax increases
-Criticism of William Proxmire
-Economic expansion
-Fiscal policy
-Tax credit compared with increased social services
-Ceiling on credit to large corporations
-Job creation
-Implementation
-Opportune time

Fiscal, monetary policy
-Effects
-1972 compared to 1970
-Need for expansion in 1974
-President’s previous experience
-Overexpansion in 1969
-Budget
-Federal Reserve
-Credit supply reduction
-Mild recession
-Stein’s speech
-Compared to 1960
-Economy
-1969
-Unemployment
-Decline
-Budget measures
-Money supply
-William McChesney Martin, Jr.
-Restrictions
-Federal Reserve
-Pressure from Wall Street, international monetary situation
-Martin
-1954, 1958, 1960, 1970 recessions
-1972 economy
-Anticipation for 1974
-Credit supply reduction
-Present dangers
-15-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Federal Reserve
-Need for restrictions
-Concern about economic growth
-Bankers
-Profits from high interest rates

US economy
-Higher prime interest rate
-Bankers’ complaints
-Corporate profits
-Published figures compared to unpublished figures
-Federal Reserve profits
-Profits of subsidiaries of American corporations abroad
-Level of domestic, nonfinancial business
-Manufacturing, mining, construction trade
-1972 compared to 1966
-Relation with Gross National Product [GNP] growth
-Commercial banks
-Growth in profits 1972 compared to 1966
-Source of profits in 1972, 1971
-Foreign investments
-Corporate profits
-Low level
-Problems
-Investment
-Productivity
-Technology
-International competitiveness
-Exportation of quality capital
-Report by CEA
-Stein
-Necessity for reinvestment
-Long-term economic strength, prosperity
-Investment in US
-Foreign investment
-Encouragement
-Further discussion
-Cabinet meeting
-Secretaries of Commerce, Labor
-16-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Working paper
-Danger of over optimism
-Tumor metaphor

Long-term planning and implementation
-Foreign policy
-People's Republic of China [PRC]
-Background of initiative
-US-Soviet Union relations
-Economy
-Budget for fiscal year 1974-1975
-Productivity
-Investment tax credit

Quadriad’s report
-Volcker
-Letter to Willy Brandt

Exchange rates change
-Realignment
-Devaluation
-Psychological impact
-Speculation
-Lack of confidence
-Administration’s responsibility
-Treasury Department, Federal Reserve’s response
-Lower discount lending rates
-Public statements
-Investors’ responses
-Currency speculation
-Swiss Franc, German Mark, gold

Fixed compared to floating currency regime
-Europe
-Fixed and floating exchange rates
-Floating regime
-Uncertainty
-President’s letter to Brandt
-Europe
-17-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Movement toward floating regime
-New trend
-Reluctance
-Floating regime
-Market reaction to change
-Weakness
-Speculation
-Fluctuation in exchange rates
-Domestic confidence
-Leadership
-Monetary reform
-Fluidity of situation
-Bolstering of US dollar
-Fixed exchange rate
-Possible future
-Problems
-Commitment to chosen policy
-President’s poker metaphor
-Fixed exchange rate regime
-US purchase of West German Marks
-Borrowing
-Exchange rate change
-Risk
-Guarantees
-West Germany’s position on floating regime
-Willy Brandt’s meeting with Edward R. G. Heath
-Statements
-Brandt’s letter to President
-Shultz's conversation with Anthony P. L. Barber
-Joint floating of currency
-Heath
-Mark pegged to British pound
-Reluctance
-Europe’s stabilization
-Barber
-Meeting with European finance ministers
-Limited financial commitment to stabilization
-Impact of European float
-Limitations, difficulty
-18-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)



European floating currency regime
-Two kinds
-Joint float
-Rigid exchange rates float against US dollar
-Individual float against US dollar
-Joint float
-Difficulty
-Disparity
-West Germany, France, Italy [?], Great Britain [?]
-European motives
-Unity
-Dollar reserves

Exchange rate system
-Changes since August 1971 exchange rate action
-Flexibility
-Floating of currencies
-Japan, Great Britain, Italy, Switzerland, Canada
-Pressure on others who don't float
-Great Britain, Canada
-Effect on relations with US
-US exchange rate
-West German Mark
-Stabilization by intervention
-Small nations
-Europeans
-Inter-European trade
Compared to trade with US
-Importance
-Impact of joint float
-Stability
-US monetary policy
-Flexibility
-Support for joint float in Europe
-Problems at home
-Psychological, political, economic risks
-Joint float
-Impact if falls apart
-19-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)



US intervention in currency exchange rate stabilization
-Recommendation
-Call from Alfred Hayes of New York Federal Reserve Bank
-West Germany
-Cooperation
-Attitude toward intervention
-Great Britain
-Support for floating exchange rates
-Heath
-France
-Support for fixed rates
-Japan
-Reaction
-New York bankers
-Preferences for fixed exchange rates
-West Germany
-Preferences
-Brandt
-US pressure
-Support
-Impact on international monetary situation
-Crisis
-Smithsonian Agreement
-Instability
-Foreign policy implications compared with domestic policy
-US leadership
-Recurrence of instability
-Pressures on US dollar convertibility
-Domestic situation
New international monetary system
-Breton Woods
-US leadership
-Flexibility, rules
-Maintenance of US exchange rate
-Condition
-Fixed compared to floating exchange rates
-Shultz
-Floating exchange rates
-20-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Burns
-US intervention
-Stabilization
-Speculators
-Risk
-Multinational declaration of rules
-Timing

Negotiations
-Foot dragging by other nations
-West Germany’s position
-US position
-Greater flexibility
-Transition to floating exchange rates
-Bubbles [?]
-US intervention
-Burns
-Long-term solution
-Europe
-Shultz
-Europe’s position
-France
-Europe’s independence
-US position
-Brandt
-Need for general rules
-Europe’s assumption
-US position at Paris meeting
-Non-intervention
-West Germany’s position
-US, France
-US Devaluation, pressure on Japan


*******************************************************************
BEGIN WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
[National security]
[Duration: 8s]
-21-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)



INTELLIGENCE


END WITHDRAWN ITEM NO. 1
******************************************************************************


-Europe’s view of US
-Source of monetary instability
-Unreliability

Monetary system
-Europe’s moves to reconstruct
-France
-US leadership
-Floating regime
-Smithsonian agreements
-Failure
-Europe’s reconstruction efforts
-US position
-Exchange rate
-Burns’s survey of economists
-Trends
-Inflationary pressures
-Economic downturn
-Ability to maintain exchange rate parity
-US intervention
-Necessity
-Prevention of further devaluation
-Method
-Borrowing from Treasury Department
-Benefits
-Dangers
-Devaluation
-Fixed exchange rate regime
-US leadership
-Europe’s position
-West Germany, Great Britain, France
-22-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Defense of parity
-Compared to flexible exchange regime
-US ability to maintain
-Massive US intervention
-Agreement on monetary reform
-Massive US intervention
-Risks
-West Germany
-Discussions with Europeans

US political relations with Europe
-Increase in contacts
-North Atlantic Treaty Organization [NATO]
-Mutual and Balanced Force Reductions [MBFR]
-European security conference
-Watershed period
-West Germany
-France
-Algeria, Vietnam
-Great Britain
-Europe’s domestic politics
-Left-wing pressures
-West Germany
-France
-Italy
-Great Britain
-Labour government
-Heath
-US relations with Union of Soviet Socialist Republics [USSR]
-Europe’s reaction
-Heath
-Discussions about US policies
-President’s trip to People’s Republic of China [PRC]
-Strategic arms talks
-Middle East
-British power
-European Union
-Europe’s relations with US
-Significance of US policy
-23-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Tendency to turn inward, isolationist
-Europe’s leaders
-Brandt
-Italy
-Administration’s goals in Europe
-European military strength
-Need for closer ties
-Preventing socialist, communist politics
-Economic partnership

US economic policies
-Review with Henry A. Kissinger
-Options
-President's decisions
-Shultz’s viewpoint
-Speech at International Monetary Fund [IMF]
-Role of US
-Political implications
-President's responsibilities
-Europe’s position
-France

US intervention in international monetary situation
-West Germany
-Great Britain
-France
-Brandt's letter
-Answer
-West German finance minister’s meeting

Kissinger meeting with Quadriad
-Scheduling
-President

US intervention
-Other actions
-Eurodollar market, Treasury bonds
-Tightening
-Speculation
-24-

NIXON PRESIDENTIAL LIBRARY AND MUSEUM

Tape Subject Log
(rev. June-2010)
Conversation No. 868-8 (cont’d)


-Controls

Kissinger meeting with Quadriad

The President talked with Kissinger at an unknown time between 10:35 am and 11:50 am.

Discussion of major monetary matters
-Meeting of Quadriad
-Letter to Brandt
-Meeting with President and Shultz

[End of telephone conversation]

Letter to Brandt

An unknown person entered at an unknown time after 10:35 am.

President's meeting with Jack L. Dreyfus, Sr.

The unknown person left at an unknown time before 11:50 am.

Burns's work

President's message on welfare
-Need for reform

Shultz, et al., left at 11:50 am.
Secret White House Tapes |

868–8

This recording is currently not available on millercenter.org. To listen to it, please email Mike Greco at mdg4u@virginia.edu

More Richard M. Nixon Recordings

View all Richard M. Nixon tapes
244–1
audio icon
37–43
audio icon
37–44
audio icon
37–45
audio icon
37–46
audio icon
37–47
audio icon
37–48
audio icon
37–49
audio icon
417–1
audio icon
417–10
audio icon